Checklist

Closing cookie settings without Save, tried on 3 Shopify stores after the Hertz order

CalPrivacy's Hertz order says a cookie window closed without Save reverted to allowing ad cookies. We ran it 3 times on 3 Shopify stores, not Hertz.

In brief

Technical observation, not legal advice. We closed the cookie settings window with the X and did not click Save. That is a different path from the FedEx quarterly opt-out test, which ran Reject All. We ran this sequence on three Shopify stores, not on Hertz, Dollar or Thrifty websites.

The order and our three stores

CalPrivacy's Enforcement Division alleged that, for part of the period the order covers, the "Manage Cookies" window on Dollar.com and Thrifty.com opened with toggles that showed every cookie category as off. The order states that if a visitor closed the window with the "X" without selecting "Save Changes", the settings did not hold and reverted to defaults that allowed advertising cookies (paragraphs 45 and 46). The order also says this design "may have been confusing" (paragraph 49). Hertz neither admits nor denies those findings (paragraph 68) and agreed to a $1,550,000 fine (paragraph 54). Read the CalPrivacy announcement and the order for the exact wording.

For each store we opened the cookie settings window, switched advertising off if it was on, then either saved or closed the window with the X. We also opened and closed it without touching anything. Each state ran three times, and we counted the requests that went to advertising and analytics vendors on the next page.

  • Store BA: after Targeting was switched off and the window was closed with the X, no choice was stored, reopening the window showed Targeting on, and the product page sent Google Ads 17, Pinterest 4, TikTok 2, Meta 2, Reddit 2, Snap 1 and GA4 2 requests, 3 of 3 runs. With Save preferences instead, only GA4 2 remained.
  • Store AE: after the data sales switch was turned off and the window was closed with the X, the store's own record still said data sales and sharing were on, and the product page sent Google Ads 18, Pinterest 8, TikTok 8 or 9, Meta 4 and GA4 2 requests, 3 of 3 runs. With Save, none of those vendors appeared on the product page.
  • Store AW: the Advertising switch showed off the moment the window opened, with no choice stored and Shopify's API never reading no. The product page still sent Google Ads 19, Meta 6, GA4 3 and Reddit 2 requests, 3 of 3 runs.

Whether any of this matches what the order describes for Dollar.com and Thrifty.com is a legal question we do not answer. The numbers are what the browser sent.

Swipe to see the order

What the order states

ParagraphWhat the order states
43The "Manage Cookies" link opens a window where consumers can accept or reject functionality, performance and advertising cookies.
45For a portion of the relevant time period, the window "displayed toggles that indicated that all the cookies were turned off".
46If the consumer closed the window, such as with the "X" at the top right, without selecting "Save Changes", "the settings would not hold. The settings reverted to the default settings, which allowed advertising cookies."
48The window "did not clearly indicate whether any action was required to decline advertising cookies".
49Requiring "an additional and non-obvious step" used choice architecture that "may have been confusing".
56(c)Hertz must test its configurations at least quarterly, including "network activity, tracking technology execution, storage writes, and system behavior before and after an opt-out request", and "for consent preference changes".

The order names Dollar.com and Thrifty.com for this finding. The order says Hertz admits paragraphs 1 to 5 and 24 to 29 and otherwise neither admits nor denies the facts, and does not admit liability.

The test we ran

The method below is ours. The order does not prescribe test steps.

We used headless Chrome from a California IP address on November 18, 2026 (PST), with a clean profile for every run, over HTTP/1.1 only. For each store we opened the home page, waited for the banner, opened the cookie settings window, then did one of these:

  1. Fresh. Click nothing. Reopen the window later only to read the switches.
  2. Off, then Save. Switch advertising off if it was on, then click the Save button.
  3. Off, then close. Switch advertising off, then close the window with the X. No Save.
  4. Open, then close. Open the window, change nothing, close it with the X.
  5. Reject. Use the Reject button on the banner or in the window. Store AE has no Reject button, so it has no fifth state.

After the click we waited, opened the third product link on the home page, and watched for about 30 seconds. We read the switch states from the page, the consent record each banner keeps, and Shopify's Customer Privacy API. We counted requests that left the browser for Meta, TikTok, Google Ads and Floodlight, GA4, Microsoft Ads, Pinterest, Snap, Reddit, Amazon Ads, LiveIntent, Attentive and Impact. Scripts and images were not counted. Status codes came from Chrome's network log. No counted request returned a 4xx or 5xx, and none used HTTP/2. About 6 percent of the counted requests have no recorded status because the page moved on before a response came back.

To keep the three states comparable, we reopened the window at the end of each run and read the advertising switch. That reopen is not part of the request counts.

Store BA: closing without Save put the Targeting switch back on

Store BA uses a Pandectes banner with Preferences and Accept on the first layer. The settings window has Functional, Performance and Targeting switches, plus Reject all, Accept all, Save preferences and a close button.

Swipe to see the product page

Store BA

StateStored consentTargeting switch on reopenProduct page requests
Freshnoneon, 3 of 3Google Ads 17 or 18, Pinterest 4, TikTok 2, Meta 2, Reddit 2, Snap 1, GA4 2 (code G111)
Targeting off, Save preferencescustom, targeting false; Shopify marketing nooff, 3 of 3GA4 2 (code G101) only
Targeting off, close with Xnoneon, 3 of 3same vendors as Fresh, Google Ads 17, other counts as Fresh, 3 of 3
Open, close with Xnoneon, 3 of 3same vendors as Fresh, Google Ads 17, other counts as Fresh, 3 of 3
Reject all (in the window)deny; Shopify marketing nooff, 3 of 3none of the vendors, 3 of 3

On Store BA the switch was off before the close and on again when we reopened the window. Meta also received a button click event for each of those clicks, described in Meta logged the click.

Store AE: Save stopped eight vendors, closing recorded a dismiss

Store AE shows a banner with Accept and a Your Privacy Choices button. Its window has one switch, Data Sales and Sharing, which is on when the window opens, plus Save and a close X. There is no Reject button. Shopify's API read marketing yes and sale_of_data yes before any click.

Swipe to see the product page

Store AE

StateBanner's own recordSwitch on reopenProduct page requests
Freshdata sales true, no method, not saved; Shopify yes, yeson, 3 of 3Google Ads 18 to 20, Pinterest 8 to 10, TikTok 8 or 9, Meta 4 or 5, GA4 2 to 4, Amazon 3, UET 1, LiveIntent 3, Attentive 2, Impact 1
Switch off, Savedata sales false, method save; Shopify no, nooff, 3 of 3Google Ads, Pinterest, TikTok, Meta, GA4, UET, Amazon and LiveIntent all 0; Attentive 2, Impact 1; 3 of 3
Switch off, close with Xdata sales true, method dismiss; Shopify yes, yeson, 3 of 3Google Ads 18, Pinterest 8, TikTok 8 or 9, Meta 4, GA4 2, Amazon 3, UET 1, LiveIntent 3, Attentive 2, Impact 1
Open, close with Xdata sales true, method dismiss; Shopify yes, yeson, 3 of 3Google Ads 18, Pinterest 8, TikTok 8 or 9, Meta 4, GA4 2, Amazon 3, UET 1, LiveIntent 3, Attentive 2, Impact 1

After Save, two Attentive requests and one Impact request still went out on the product page, the same counts as Fresh, 3 of 3. Three TikTok requests also left the home page after Save, 3 of 3: two at +2,240 to +4,661 ms after the click, and a third at +12,240 to +14,652 ms. None followed on the product page. We cannot see why these were sent.

Store AW: the Advertising switch showed off before any choice existed

Store AW uses a CookieFirst banner with Accept all, Reject All and Preferences. The settings window has Necessary, Performance, Functional and Advertising switches, plus Save settings and a close X. The Advertising switch already showed off when we opened the window, so on this store "switch advertising off" needed no click.

Swipe to see the product page

Store AW

StateStored consentAdvertising switchProduct page requests
Freshnone; Shopify's API blank, 3 of 3off when read, 3 of 3Google Ads 19, Meta 6, GA4 3, Reddit 2
Open, close with Xnone; Shopify's API blank, 3 of 3off before and after, 3 of 3same as Fresh, 3 of 3
Advertising off, close with Xnone; Shopify's API blank in 2 runs, yes in 1 run (yes before the click)off before and after, 3 of 3same vendors as Fresh, Meta 6 or 7, 3 of 3
Advertising off, Save settingsall optional categories false; Shopify no, nooff, 3 of 3GA4 3 (code G100) only, 3 of 3
Reject All (banner)all optional categories false; Shopify no, nooff, 3 of 3GA4 3 to 6 (code G100); Meta 0 in 2 runs and 3 in 1 run; Google Ads 0

Of the 19 Google Ads requests on the Fresh product page, 13 carried a Consent Mode code in every run, and all 13 read G111, which means advertising and analytics storage granted. On Store AW the window showed the switch off while no choice was stored and these vendors ran, 3 of 3.

After Save settings, in all 3 runs, five Google Ads requests (code G111) and a Meta PageView and ViewContent left the home page after the click. Relative to the click, Google Ads started at +1,141 to +2,152 ms and Meta at +1,250 to +1,985 ms. After Reject All, the same vendors left the home page in all 3 runs, Google Ads at +1,312 to +2,064 ms and Meta at +1,498 to +1,585 ms. The product page that followed had no Google Ads requests, 3 of 3, and no Meta requests in 2 of 3 runs (3 Meta requests in 1 run). We did not find out why these home-page requests were sent.

Meta logged the click

Meta received a SubscribedButtonClick event carrying the text of the button that was clicked. On Store BA it carried Save preferences, Close or Reject all, 3 of 3 for each. On Store AW it carried Save settings, Close or Reject All, 3 of 3 for each. On Store AE it carried Save, 3 of 3, and nothing was sent when the window was closed with the X, 0 of 3. We saw the same kind of event on the reject click in the FedEx test.

How to run this test on your own store

  1. Pick a clean browser profile in a region you serve. Open the home page and let the banner settle.
  2. Open the cookie settings window from the banner or the footer. Photograph every switch before you touch anything.
  3. In Network, filter for the ad vendors you run. Note the count on the first page before any click.
  4. Switch advertising off, then close the window with the X. Do not click Save. Load a product page and count again.
  5. Reopen the window and photograph the switches. Note whether the advertising switch moved back.
  6. Repeat from a fresh profile, this time clicking Save. Count again.
  7. Repeat once more, opening the window and closing it with no change.
  8. Read Shopify's Customer Privacy API in the console after each step. Why Shopify's API and the pixels can disagree.
  9. Run all three states at least three times. Write down any run that differs.

If you also want the Reject and GPC paths checked, our quarterly opt-out test walks through both.

What to write down

Swipe to see the example

Example from Store BA

FieldExample from Store BA
Date, time, locationNovember 18, 2026 PST, California IP
StateTargeting off, close with X
Switch shown after reopeningon
Consent storednone
Vendors on the next page7 of the 7 seen on a fresh visit
Vendors that stoppednone
Status codesall 200 or 204
Runs that matched3 of 3

Limits

  • Three stores, one California location, one night, November 18, 2026 PST. Stores change their settings and a later run can differ.
  • None of these stores is Hertz, Dollar or Thrifty. We did not see their windows and we did not test the pages the order describes.
  • We counted requests leaving the browser. We did not see what vendors do with them or whether anything is sent server to server.
  • Cookie names written before the first click were still present at the end of every state, so the cookie list does not separate the states. We did not compare cookie values.
  • We tested a clean first visit, not a logged-in visitor, checkout, a mobile app or a staging site, all of which the order's paragraph 56(c) covers for Hertz.
  • We did not test GPC in this post.
  • Store letters match our earlier posts. Store BA is the store in Pandectes Shopify Reject test and Store AW is the store in CookieFirst Shopify Reject test.

FAQ

What did CalPrivacy say about Hertz's cookie settings window?

CalPrivacy's Enforcement Division alleged that on Dollar.com and Thrifty.com the "Manage Cookies" window showed all toggles as off, and that closing it with the X without selecting "Save Changes" meant the settings did not hold and reverted to defaults that allowed advertising cookies. Hertz neither admits nor denies this and agreed to a $1,550,000 fine.

Did you test Hertz's websites?

No. We tested three Shopify stores that have a cookie settings window. The results describe those stores on November 18, 2026 PST and say nothing about Hertz, Dollar or Thrifty.

What happened when the window was closed without Save?

On Store BA, no choice was stored, the Targeting switch was back on when we reopened the window, and the same vendors ran as on a fresh visit, 3 of 3. On Store AE, the banner's record read data sales and sharing true with method dismiss, and the same vendors ran as on a fresh visit, 3 of 3. On Store AW, no choice was stored and the same four vendors ran as on a fresh visit, 3 of 3.

Does Save stop the ad requests?

On Store AE, no Google Ads, Pinterest, TikTok, Meta, GA4, UET, Amazon or LiveIntent request appeared on the product page after Save, 3 of 3, while Attentive 2 and Impact 1 requests still did. On Store BA, only GA4 2 requests appeared (code G101), 3 of 3. On Store AW, only GA4 3 requests appeared (code G100), 3 of 3. On Store AW, five Google Ads requests and a Meta PageView and ViewContent left the home page after Save and after Reject All, 3 of 3, at the times in the Store AW section. On Store AE, three TikTok requests left the home page after Save, 3 of 3, at the times in the Store AE section.

Does the order require a test like this?

Paragraph 56(c) requires Hertz to test its configurations at least quarterly, including network activity, storage writes and behavior before and after an opt-out request and for consent preference changes. The order does not list the steps, and the steps in this post are ours.

Sources

These links cover the platform and regulatory context used in this guide. Applicability still depends on the organization and jurisdiction.

Close cookie settings without Save, 3 stores | ConsentProbe